Michael Dwyer death: Political plot or Bolivian bovine?

Following the shooting dead of Michael Martin Dwyer from Ballinderry, County Tipperary in the town of Santa Cruz in Bolivia, local media in that country tried and convicted him of being involved in a band of international mercenaries, funded by right wing groups hell bent on destableizing the left-wing government of Evo Morales. But the official story has more holes in it than the walls of the hotel rooms where these men died.

The politicians in Bolivia cannot be believed due to the extreme politics on both ends of the spectrum. Bolivia has never really had a stable government since it gained independence.

Bolivian media cannot be trusted either as they would be alligned to either the left or the right. There is no real “newspaper of record” in the country.

The claims about the killing have ranged from the five men were killed for political show, and that there were no conspiracy to kill Morales, to one crazy claim that renagade freemasons funded the supposed assassination attempt.

But as Dwyer was from our part of the world, let’s focus on him. The profile of an international assassin, he does not fit. The Junior Minister for Foreign Affairs, Dick Roche stated on RTE radio this morning that Dwyer had never come to the attention of the Guards here.

Initial reports in Bolivian media claimed that Dwyer was involved in the Balkan war. The Balkan war ended when Dwyer was in his early teens, so this is not likely.

The media, both in Bolivia, and here, printed pictures of Dwyer in military garb. This too does not make him fit the profile of a mercenary. The photos were taken during Airsoft outings. Airsoft is a sport where enthusiasts get to play soldier with guns that fire small pellets. The only difference between someone who does airsoft and someone who likes shoot-em-up videogames in my book would be that the airsoft guy gets fresh air and excersise.

Dwyer himself was barely out of college, having graduated from GMIT in 2008, he went to Galway to work in security before going to America. It wasn’t his intention to stay there as he was due home again at the end of this year.

The “Shoot-out”

It was claimed that there was a half hour shoot out between the elite army unit and the so-called “mercenaries. However, the proprietor of the hotel where the men stayed has denied this. The men were also accused of taking refuge in the hotel after being chased by this army unit. However, press photographs show that the dead men were in their underwear. Dwyer is shown in one photograph lying beside his bed. There were no guns in the photographs of the corpeses, nor are there any shell casings.

There is one bullet hole in the wall of Dwyer’s room, and that was fired from the room’s door where the army unit entered. Hardly indicative of a half hour gun battle.

It is also worth mentioning that despite there supposedly being a gun battle, where it is claimed a grenade was used, there is no report of a single member of the army unit being injured.

Weapons, supposedly stashed away in preparation for the assassination, were “found” as much as a a mile away , even though the police claimed they were in a nearby building. A mile isn’t all that near.

Several photographs of the dead men show that their hands were tied. Since when did it become necessary to tie dead men up. If their hands were tied while they were alive, why was it necessary to kill them if they could not return fire due to they’re being restrained in this manner?

Michael Dwyer’s remains have been released to Irish consular officials for repatriation back to Ireland. It would be prudent that a propper, and trustworthy autopsy be carried out by our own state pathologist on it’s arrival.

While the case for this being a load of Bolivian Bovine is quite strong, there are certain questions which require answering.

How did a young Irishman end up working security in one of the most dangerous countries in South America. What company thought it would be a good place to get training, which has been claimed in the Irish media.

On his Bebo page, Dwyer claimed that he liked cruisin around in his BMW. Not exactly a cheap banger, where did the money for this come from after only a few months in the country?

How did Dwyer become friends with a former Balkan war veteran, Eduardo Rozca Flores. Dwyer was one of his friends on the Facebook social networking site. They were both killed on Thursday.

  • ollieboyle29
    Hi i didnt know micheal , im a 29 year old security guard from dublin, i dont have a degree in international politics, i am not affilated with this man grieving family nor am i affilated or know anyone in bolivia. But what i do know is a blind man can see this is a cover up !! I thought this from the very start ??? You would have to be bananaz or brain washed to believe a COCK AND BULL fantascy dreamed up by these bolivianz! I am out raged to my core that this poor family had to see pictures of their son brother lying on a cold slab !!! I am also out raged with the irish media on the first couple of days splashing ludricious headlines about this man and stabbing the family again with his picture of him dead!Then after a few days the media realising this story was untrue and slowly fading into the shadows without words of apology or compensation for this family.

    This is not on lads, we dont live on an island where we put everyday grusome pictures on the front page to sell poxie papers! Just cause some other country does, does it give us the go ahead to follow suit ! No and it never has, unless the family or gardai requests such a motion and normally this is to help some investigation not to sell papers.

    My heart goes out to this man who is a son of our land and a family member to a family who seem like a really loving nice irish family, a man who grew up on this land and probably held a heartfull of love for the irish soil , its people and all around him........

    ............only in death to be let down by those who should have @ least stuck up for him or vindicate him from this trumped up crime i.e the government and media should hang their heads in shame until this young proud irish mans name is cleared. I shudder to think that Ireland has lost its love and personality for those law biding citizen who make our small little ireland famous for all the reasons internationally known in the world today.

    My prayers and thought are with the dwyer family
    I wish uou all the best of luck in your fight for justice
    And if i can help in any way please say....
  • margaritalatina
    First of all the pictures were printed by the right wing press to shock people. So, don't blame the Bolivian government for that.
    Secondly, if you do not want to end up like that do not go to Bolivia to try terrorist attacks. Our goverment will not tolerate that. We are peaceful people, but how would you feel if we arrived in Ireland and started blowing bombs. That's what Michael D, did, and I'm glad they were shot while they were in bed, otherwise they would have blown the hotel to pieces and then everybody would say how imcompetent the Bolivian police is.
  • Sean
  • Con Maxwell
    To Julio Carrasco,
    It is absolutely nonsensical to state that Evo Morales wants a cultural revolution on the Mao Tse Tung or Pol Pot style.This is typical of the type of rubbish propogated by the right wing press in Latin America, newspapers which openly insult people because of their racial origin, something which is not allowed in developed countries.I am a regular visitor to Latin America and I see what I have just described
  • Julio Carrasco
    Con Maxwell, The president of Bolivia was democratically elected, yes, but now he had declared that he is Marxist, Leninist, Socialist and Comunist and he wants toled our cuntry toward a Cultural Revolution in the MaoTse Tung-Pol Pot style. Killing an irish man doesn´t mean nothing in a Stalinist plot to implant in Bolivia a dictator.
  • Daffyd
    Oh for pity's sake
  • Daniel
    Someone that works in international security is a mercenary. That's precisely what international security work is. Whether Dwyer was an extreme right winger like the Hungarian or "just doing his job", he was definitely involved in something shady.
  • Con Maxwell
    To Maria from Bolivia I direct the following:
    Coca leaf has both licit and illicit uses.You can buy it legally in shops in Latin America in a form like tea bags.It is a mild stimulant and is said to be good for altitude sickness.So not everyone who grows coca is a criminal.
    In Bolivia as in the rest of Latin America the white people (whose ancestors arrived there a few centuries or a few generations ago) occupy the flat good land while the indigenous people (whose ancestors arrived there 20,000 years ago) live on tiny plots of land on the sides of the Andes.The indigenous people were driven from their lands.It is very difficult for these people to survive.
    Some of the Bolivian poor try to emigrate.However quotas and visa problems make this very difficult.Here in Spain where I live there are a lot of Bolivians, some of them illegal (or "sin papeles" as it is called here).Being illegal puts them in danger of labour exploitation and hassle from the police.Seeing the difficulties these people face at home or abroad is it any wonder that some of them unfortunately resort to profitably growing coca for illicit purposes?.
    As regards political violence from the left, this is often a last resort for people who know that state institutions (police, courts etc) are totally corrupt under right wing governments and only serve the interests of the rich.Morales is a saint in comparison with his recent predecessors.
  • Daffyd
    The more I read of this case, the more I am being convinced of Dwyer's complicity in whatever these - lets call a spade a spade - fascists were plotting.

    Some very pertinent questions raised in today's Irish Times as to what he was doing over in Bolivia in the first place. His family say the security company he worked for sent him over for 3 months training, experts here say they have never heard of such a practice.

    I could go further down the road of what I know at this point but I'd be threading into speculative territory.

    Better to stick to what we know, but Integrated Risk Management Services, Dwyers employers here, should release a statement. I'm not sure if the family even have the full story as to what Michael Dwyer was up to in Bolivia.
  • Jack
    How sure are you that he worked with IRMS ?. Did IRMS send him down to Bolivia?, Was he representing IRMS when he was in Bolivia ?
  • Matt
    He is work for IRMS since febuary 2008. He was a Team Leader in my group.
  • zippo
    This all sounds like a cheap james bond movie!!! to answer the questions on what was an Irishman doing in bolivia? simple!! jobs are not easy to come accross in this country so a man has to work where a man has to work!!!
    Furthermore
    "On his Bebo page, Dwyer claimed that he liked cruisin around in his BMW. Not exactly a cheap banger, where did the money for this come from after only a few months in the country?"
    BMW's in Bolivia are not that expensive!!!

    I dont know mike!! but I can be sure that he is innocent an did not deserve to die!!! i only hope that justice is served here and the army unit that carried out these murders pays for what it has done!!
  • Matt
    I know Mike well. I work with him last year and i dont belive for this shit.
  • Martin
    I am afraid that I don't believe that Dwyer is completely innocent; in fact I believe that he liked to play soldiers and got killed for his naive adventure, what a Muppet? If this is the case then he deserved his end and our government should not pay for his repatriation.

    I have been to Bolivia many times and while I agree with some of the points you raised, Bolivia is a country that has been robbed by successive right wing governments which were supported by foreign pillaging companies.
    Our media can be just as submissively selective as the Bolivian.

    I hope that our media focus in on the questions that you raised at the end as they need to be addressed by his family and friends before we all mistakenly sympathise with his end.

    I hope my initial thoughts are incorrect and if his innocence transpires I recant this message.
  • It is well known... the three man where shot to dead on their beds at 4:00 am. Evo Morales see enemies or plots in any face on the streets. Something that happens always to small "leaders" trying any way to continue ruling this country and become a "hero" for history.
  • squidlimerick
    Seamus Fogerty comment reposted here

    Ms Mcnamara,
    Thank's for that article, actually it dors ask some of my questions as well, and as far as the bolivian press goes, I take there stuff with a grain of salt, and Mr Dwyer cruising around in a BMW, where did the Money come for that Car ??????
    Still I wonder what was mr Dwyer (RIP) doing there in the first place??
    I was arount that part of the world in 1955/6/7/8/9/60, but only got into a little bit of trouble on Two
  • G M
    This is the biggest conspiracy since JFK! Fookin Bolivian drug loving bastards, Mike was deff in no way attempting or conspiring to Kill Morales! Theres more than meets the eye in all this! Might have something to do with drugs (maybe) but Mike was no international hitman for hire, mercenary, assassin or whatever else the Bolivian authorities are painting him out to be! I hope Morales dies an awful, painful death after this, bastard deserves to die!

    R.I.P Mikey, will dearly miss our paintballin sessions
  • Maria
    I am Bolivian, and I think you are right. This is a holliwood set organised to put in prison Bolivian oponents to the actual regime. Unfortunatelly your dear friend was in the the wrong place at the wrong moment.
    Can you call Morales to lead a democracy?
    Did you know that The vice rpesident of Bolivia was a real terorist? and nobody killed him...and he went to prison for trying to bomb few buildings in Bolivia.
    Sorry about that , I am ashamed to be Bolivian.
    Morales is a criminal and the Vice president is worst than that.
    Morales is teh elader of teh Coca growers...Coca teh raw material for cocaine. I mean the leader, can you imagine, the president to be a cocaine raw material provider?
  • Daffyd
    LOL!

    I like the bringing up of his role as leader of the indigineous coca farmers and attempting to play on western ignorance of the coca plant and it's importance to the indigineous peoples of Latin America.

    I'm assuming you've heard of Nacion Camba too? Branko Marinkovic? They're the kind of people who prowl around the opposition's strongholds brandishing swatiskas and beating and murdering Indians for being Indians.

    You should be ashamed, you should be ashamed that many of your countrymen have so little regard for democracy that they're prepared to drag Bolivia back to the bad old days Europe experienced in the 30s/40s and Latin America did in the 50s/60s/70s/80s.

    Flores was a fascist and a racist, his previous writings and pronouncements leave no room for doubt on that front, and that he was up to no good is a given. It's just a crying shame that a young Irishman seemed to get embroiled in a situation which was way over his head.
  • Con Maxwell
    It is incorrect to state that "all politicians in Bolivia cant be believed due to the extreme politics at both ends of the spectrum".There is nothing extreme about the present Bolivian government.It won an election and is trying to bring some dignity and justice to the majority of the population, something they have been denied for five centuries.
    The opposition meanwhile, based in Santa Cruz, is an extremely corrupt elite, who cant accept losing an election and some of their priveleges.These type of people have been in power throughout Latin America since colonisation.Independence in the early 1800s made no difference.They have ruled either through totally corrupted democracy or through the military, when they feel their power slipping.
  • squidlimerick
    Hitler won an election.
  • Steve
    How did a young Irishman end up working security in one of the most dangerous countries in South America.

    As someone who has lived in Bolivia I can assure you that it's not at all dangerous. There is more violent crime in Dublin than the capital La Paz.

    Argentina, Brazil, Peru, Equador, Bolivia's surrounding countries, have far, far more violent and organised crime.

    There's a lot of political instability though...
  • You can also see his Youtube page where Eduardo was online a few hours before he was shot....
    http://www.youtube.com/user/ed...
  • I met Eduardo Rozsa Flores first time like 10 years back and I had an Argentinian friend who was jailed and tortured for his political views visiting me in Budapest. Having spent many years in Sweden, Eduardo showed me some poems he had written in Swedish in the few years he had spent there with his family back in the 1970`s, there was a bullet ridden car door hanging on one wall of his flat, a memory of his near escapes in Croatia. There was even a bust of a Jewish Croatian Nazi. There were several people sitting in the kitchen having some discussion, bearded intellectuals and some women who looked like librarians or art critics in spectacles. He had some sort of open house policy and people seemed to just drop by. My first meeting left a strong impression on me and was very kind hearted. The Serbs hated him and there have been many claims trying to discredit him, supposedly killing 2 foreign journalists? I doubt it though. He was a troubled soul but no assassin, probably they might have been up to something dodgy but an assassination plot with some far right backers, no way Hose! But I guess he went down like Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid with a bang.
  • J. Byrne
    The coont wanted action. The coont got action. Mercenaries = scum.
  • Susan
    I diden't know you mike ,,,,,, R.I.P.
  • pat
    Eduardo Rozca Flores "appears" to be an honorable experienced war veteran, it would seem unlikely a man of this ilk would be involved in such an amateur assassination attempt. I just seems odd that would be skilled president assassins would sleep in the same hotel.
blog comments powered by Disqus