Kevin walsh, with a promising life in front of him, will never sit his Leaving Cert, and celebrate the results with his friends. He will never take a girl out for his debs, he will never have a 21st, he will never marry, and he will never bless his parents with grandchildren. Why, because he is dead.
How did he die? Early one morning in 2006, the uncles he was travelling with acted out of concern for living things and stopped to inform Gardai that there were farm animals on the road they were travelling. While they were doing this, a 4×4 jeep, with Eddie Halvey at the wheel, ploughed into the back of their car, killing young Kevin as he sat in the rear passenger seat.
Halvey was found to be twice the legal limit for alcohol following the collision which left Kevin Walsh dead.
The courts and the media will call this careless driving. But the fact remains, that Kevin Walsh will never have the life experiences listed in the first paragraph of this post because of what happened on that morning in 2006.
After three years of legal drama, the late Kevin Walsh’s family finally learned how much value the judiciary put on human life. Eddie Halvey received a seven month suspended sentence for his actions. Is it any wonder the criminal fraternity put such a low value on human life, when the judiciary appear to feel the same way.
So who judges the judges? When everyone else was being asked to take on pension levies, and pay cuts, the judges in this country were given a compromise deal. You can pay the pension levy being imposed on every other state employee, but only if you want to, and furthermore, you don’t have to make it public if you are paying it or not. You would be forgiven for thinking that those who are the law, consider themselves to be above the law.
While an American style election for judges would be detremental to justice, I do believe that there should be a mechanism in place for members of the public to petition for the removal of incompitent judges.
A simple solution would be to require the signatures of a certain percentage of registered voters in a judges district court administrative area, submitted to the Minister for Justice, who would then be oblidged to remove said judge.
The people who are supposed to be served by these judges should be the ones to decide if they are doing a good job or not. It is pointless having Gardai working their asses off to solve crimes if a fitting punnishment cannot be handed down by the courts for these crimes. It would be like working for nothing